Resources
Jun 05,2020
Express n° 17 Case: TM | SPC: Transformed use of a registered trademark untenable in Defense of Legitimate Use
On
December 17, 2019, China Supreme People’s Court (SPC) maintained the first instance judgment made by
Fujian High Court, ruling in favor of Reebok in a trademark and copyright infringement
lawsuit against Jinjiang Raysun Sports Products Co., Ltd. The SPC affirmed trademark
infringement and infringement over copyrighted fine art, ordered cessation and awarded
damages of RMB 3,000,000.
Raysun asserted
legitimate use, arguing that it has been licensed to use the litigious registered
trademarks and it has copyrighted the litigious fine art. The argument was
dismissed by both courts, considering that Raysun had transformed the
registered trademarks in actual use, making it visually similar to Reebok’s
cited mark and that Reebok’s cited fine art predates the litigious fine art of Raysun.
The SPC therefore rebutted Raysun’s defense of legitimate use and concluded
that it could not be exempted from infringement liabilities.
Contributed by: Huan Xia